For every limited-edition toy purchased, Volkswagen, KONG, and VCA Charities will donate another toy to an animal shelter.

Variety: The boxes I recommend include something for every dog. Boxes with a variety of toys, such as tug toys, balls or squeaky toys, and puzzle or treat-dispensing toys, scored well in my testing.

Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy ... Bark Pupkin Spice Yappucino Tough Treat Dispensing Dog Chew Toy Bark Pupkin Spice Yappucino Tough Treat Dispensing Dog Chew Toy Spend $100 on select products ...