You never know what you’re gonna get. At Surprise Scoop, a new ice cream shop in the East Village, customers don’t get to choose a flavor. The only menu item is “surprise ice cream” ($9.18).

Step 5: Once the cones have cooled, dip the top of them in some melted chocolate and cover in unicorn multi-coloured sprinkles. Set the cones on some baking paper until the chocolate hardens.

We scooped, sampled and scored all the pints to help you find which flavors are worth scooping into your bowl or onto your ice cream cone. Read on for our ranking of 31 flavors of Graeter's ice ...